Company C, 814th Tank Destroyer Battalion
Tank Destroyer Hit at Commanster, Belgium
December 23, 1944

Bookmark this page as http://www.7thArmdDiv.org/814c-commanster.htm
Last updated: July 6, 2020 - What's New?
Stuck in someone's frames? Click here.

Contents
ordered by date created after Context & Composition

Context

The German Ardennes Offensive began December 16, 1944, along an 80-mile front. Now known as the Battle of the Bulge, it remains the largest battle ever fought by the United States Army. The Germans met with initial success in most parts of their central thrust, spearheaded by Battle Group Peiper. Their plan was for the central thrust (by Sixth SS and Fifth Panzer Armies) to be buffered by parallel thrusts to the north (Fifteenth Army) and south (Seventh Army), which would prevent American reinforcements from reaching the flanks of the main thrust toward Antwerp. However, the American troops on the northern shoulder held most of their ground, thanks to the efforts of the 99th and 2nd Infantry Divisions. This allowed the U. S. 7th Armored Division to move, on the morning of December 17, from north of Aachen, Germany to the center of the front, at St. Vith, Belgium. The move was made on an eastern route bound for St. Vith and a western route bound for Vielsalm. The 814th Tank Destroyer Battalion was not an organic element of 7th Armored Division but was attached to 7AD in August 1944 for the duration of the war in Europe. 814 TD moved south in the western column, arriving at Vielsalm late on December 17.

Although the front lines to the east at St. Vith stopped the German advance, German units penetrated westward to the north and to the south of the defenses. By December 19, the Germans had penetrated far to the west of St. Vith on the south, to the point where normally rear echelon supply units came under attack 20 miles and more west of St. Vith.

On December 23, the entire force under 7th Armored Division was withdrawn from the salient to west of the Salm River. The withdrawal in daylight, under constant attack by the enemy, was done in phased steps. Mostly things went as planned. But for some units, particularly including elements of 814th Tank Destroyer Battalion as one of the last units to withdraw, the enemy suceeded in inflicting losses of personnel and vehicles. One of those vehicles lost was C/814 tank destroyer #40177750, labeled C-22 for marches. It was hit at Commanster, Belgium, and abandoned in a stream. At least one member of the crew was killed: Pvt. Paul H. Espig. Someone -- probably either German soldiers or Belgian civilians -- buried him there. In late March 1945, the American Graves Registration Service was notified of the isolated burial. On 4 May 1945, a GRS unit working out of the temporary U. S. Military Cemetery at Foy, Belgium, recovered the remains and labeled them as Unknown X-127 (Foy).

This web page is about these men of the 814th Armored Division and their role in the combat that took at least one of their lives and may have left others wounded or captured. There has been an absence until now of detailed material about this event, and this web page is intended to provide that detail, to bring to light the men and events of this little-known part of the battle. -- Wesley Johnston, Historian, 7th Armored Division Association


After Action Report, Combat Interviews, Morning Reports
814th Tank Destroyer Battalion
After Action Report - Company C Section
23 Jan 1945

5. A plan of general withdrawal plan was announced at 0700 23 Dec with 3rd Platoon of Company C occupying high ground to SW overlooking Grombach and balance of CCB withdrawing through its position. When CCB cleared the ridge the 3rd Platoon fell in as rearguard and fought its way through Braumlauf in spite of heavy small arms and bazooka fire, towards Maidingen. Upon reaching Beho it was attached to TF Jones and acted as rear guard for that unit.

6. The 1st Platoon executed the withdrawal without contact with the enemy.

7. The 2nd Platoon with mission of covering withdrawal, found Crombach route cut so used an alternate route. At close range they repulsed enemy tank attack on Hinderhausen with the loss of two M-36's, but in the fight knocked out three Mk VI's and one Mk V. The platoon then withdrew to high ground to the SW, but the Platoon Sgt. reported that they were being encircled. One gun was ordered to Commanster while the rest of the Platoon covered CCB's withdrawal and then it withdrew to that town. Upon reaching the town it was again subjected to enemy tank attack, and in the fight knocked out one Mk VI and two Mk V's, but lost a third destroyer, which left the Platoon with only one M-36. It was then ordered to withdraw to Neuville where it set up a road block with infantry. It held this position until 1900 hours when it withdrew to Harze, Belgium without further incident.

814th Tank Destroyer Battalion
Combat Interviews
23 Jan 1945
Lt. Jack Dillender, Commanding Officer
2d Platoon, Company "C"
Interviewed 11 Jan 1945

22 Dec. Friday
On the afternoon of the 22d, 2d platoon to Hinderhausen after the TD’s had gone to Krombach as told by Capt Reid, the second platoon was ordered to Hinderhausen, and it assumed positions there just before dark. ...

23 Dec. Saturday
There was no action that night, and at daylight orders were received that the force was to cover the withdrawal of all troops in Krombach. The TD’s and tanks were to be pulled closer to town to be ready to move out.

The first destroyer had to be pulled before it would start up. The mediums pulled toward the center of town, and the TD’s were to cover the withdrawal. After this took place, Lt Dillender placed two TD’s in position to cover toward the rear (east). The troops were just being organized to withdraw, when two Mark 6 tanks came down the road from Rodt and got within 150 yards of the two TD’s. The number 2 TD immediately aimed at the first tank and fired. The gun mechanism failed. The gunner recovered and fired again, this time putting an AP shot through the front of the Tiger, setting it afire and blowing it up.

Lt Dillender left the No 1 TD and went to the No 2 and observe for the gunner. He spotted the second enemy tank. The first shot hit it, causing the crew to abandon it. Five more rounds were fired at it, and it started to burn. Some of the enemy, trying to abandon it, were shot by the infantry, and the only German who tried to get out of the first tank was shot with a rifle by the gunner of the No 1 TD.

Just as the No.2 TD was about to pull out, it received a shot in the motors from the north, causing it to burn. The gun comdr was knocked off it, the driver got out without being wounded, and Lt Dillender was hit in the leg with shrapnel, was knocked off and fell on top of the gun comdr whose back was seriously wrenched.

The gunner was taken from the tank with face burns and a bruised leg. The ast driver received serious burns about the face and body.

The wounded men were loaded on the other TD and the Lt reported to the officer in charge. He was informed that the Krombach road had been cut, and that the unit would have to pull out on unreconnoitered route. This was at 1000.

The column left town and went southwest toward Commanster. At the first high ground, a defensive position was established. Two of the TD’s were having motor trouble, the no. 3 TD not being able to get out of second gear. It was placed to cover the road. Enemy infantry and tanks, circling to the right rear, began to bore in. The tank commander, Sgt Barton H Matheson, tried to radio Lt Dillender, but his radio failed. He left the TD, crawled 1000 yards to the rest of the unit, and reported the situation. The column immediately withdrew circling to the south and took up positions in Commanster. The No 3 tank, still in second gear, managed to withdraw to Commanster on another route.

In Commanster, the gunner of no 2 TD took over the platoon sgts TD so that the latter could assist Lt Dillender.

The enemy tanks attacked again, and the No 3 tank, now run by T/5 John C Holt, with Sgt James Foss as gun cmdr knocked out an M-5, and received a shot directly through its motors. The shot passed into the fighting compartment and shattered in the asst driver’s compartment. The asst driver was outside as observer at the time and was not wounded. The driver was badly wounded. The gunner was evacuated with burns. The assistant gunner never got out.

The wounded were loaded on the remaining two TD’s, and the unit withdrew to positions at 739873, southwest of Neuville.
Here positions were organized under Col Boylan of the 87th Recon.

Two TD’s were employed in depth to cover the road from Commanster and the light tanks and infantry were organized in a perimeter defense of the destroyers. At this time, Col Boylan ordered Lt Dillender to be evacuated along with the remainder of the wounded.

The TD’s remained there until 1900, then withdrew through Neuville, Vielsalm, Salm Chateau, and Harze arriving between 0100 and 0200 24 December.

Morning Reports

The 23 December 1944 Morning Report gives the Record of Events and also some casualties of that date. The 26 December 1944 gives a retroactive report of more casualties for 23 December 1944. Note that the 26 December 1944 contains three cannoneers (MOS 531), so that it clearly has members of at least three different tank destroyer crews.

23 Dec C/814

Click on image for full size.
26 Dec C/814

Click on image for full size.

Individual Deceased Personnel File of Pvt. Paul H. Espig

Pvt. Paul H. Espig was apparently a crew member of C/814 tank destroyer #40177750 with march serial C-22 that was knocked out at Commanster 23 Dec 1944. Someone buried his remains in an isolated grave near the tank destroyer. He was recovered 4 May 1945 by a team from the 610th Quartermaster Graves Registration Company who could not identify him and labeled his remains Unknown Foy X-127. In September 1948, he was identified through private dental records sent by his family. His Individual Deceased Personnel File (IDPF) and the file for Foy X-127 would normally have been combined into his IDPF. But the lateness of the identification apparently led to the two files being kept separate. 7th Armored Division Association Historian Wesley Johnston has now combined the two files into one, which can be seen by clicking here.

In particular, the 4 May 1945 "Report of Investigation of Isolated Grave or Unburied Remains" (PDF pp 12-14) includes the following detailed map of the location of the tank destroyer and the grave.


Click on image for full size.

Click here for information about contacting me.
Copyright © 2020 by Wesley Johnston
All rights reserved

Click here for an active overview of all pages at the 7th Armored Division web site